Go(a)t Milk? Cheeses, Yogurt, Kefir and More at Little White Goat Dairy in Orange

The Recorder, November 15, 2016, by Shelby Ashline

As the sun rises over the hills of Orange, covered with golden treetops, Rachel Scherer opens the door to her rustic wooden barn.

“Come on ladies!” she calls, and with soft bleats, more than 20 goats of different sizes and colors step from the barn into the daylight.

One by one, Scherer leads each goat by its yellow collar into the milking room and, at just 6 a.m., begins her daily tasks at The Little White Goat Dairy at Heritage Fields Farm.

The Little White Goat Dairy, a 100-percent solar-powered farm at the end of Gidney Road, offers a unique selection of goat milk, yogurt, cheeses and fermented milk called kefir.

“I like to make different flavor profiles than you can get anywhere else,” Scherer said.

The business attracts local customers as well as those from central Massachusetts, many of whom are allergic to cow milk. In fact, an allergy to cow milk is part of what inspired Scherer to start The Little White Goat Dairy.

Baaa-ck to the Basics

Scherer and her husband Bruce first purchased the 81-acre farm in 1981. While working as a laboratory scientist at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, Rachel Scherer started keeping gardens and animals simply to feed her family.

“I just decided I’d really rather just go back to working at home and keeping animals,” she said.

In 2005, she and Bruce started work on the barn, completing all the construction themselves other than pouring the foundation. Being allergic to cow milk, someone recommended that Scherer try keeping goats instead, and she purchased her first Nubian-Saneen cross goats.

Her first goats, however, had very little handling and Scherer decided to increase her flock with two LaMancha goats that were more accustomed to people. She has used LaMancha goats for milking ever since.

“They were just so calm and easy to work with,” Scherer remembers.

Her third LaMancha, named Little White Goat, later became the namesake for Scherer’s business.

“She was my first really good milker,” Scherer said. “She taught me everything I needed to know.”

Getting her dairy production off the ground meant making yogurt, cheese and milk for about seven families, Scherer said, and working four to six hours a day. She decided to make the dairy a full-time business, which entailed taking United States Department of Agriculture classes for first-time farmers and applying for necessary permits.

“By fall 2013, we finally had every inspection and every permit finished,” she said. And so, The Little White Goat Dairy was officially born.

Today, the farm features 24 goats, Scherer said, including two males for breeding. The barn is meticulously divided into a milking room, a milk bottling room and another room for producing yogurt, cheeses and kefir, which she calls “the make room.”

However, not everything is exactly as Scherer had originally envisioned. For example, knowing there was only one other farm in Massachusetts producing just goat milk, Scherer originally intended to sell just milk to fill the demand. However, she quickly found a demand for a greater variety of goat products.

“It’s been successful beyond the business plan,” she said. “We had a five-year business plan and we’ve gone well past it in just our third year.”

A Hard Day’s Work

During milking season, which runs from April to December, Rachel Scherer starts her day by getting to the barn at 6 a.m. and milking each female goat — called a doe or nanny. Each goat produces between a half gallon and full gallon of milk each day.

Scherer also cleans their sleeping area, puts the milk in a tank for low temperature pasteurization, cleans the milking equipment and cares for the farm’s pigs. Heritage Fields Farm also sells pork, chicken and goat meat.

After breakfast at around 8:30 a.m., Scherer gets started on production. She adds non-GMO cultures to the milk and allows it to incubate for between four and 24 hours, depending on the product.

In the case of feta and chevre cheeses, she said, the mixture separates into curds and whey. The whey is drained.

Often, the next day is spent seasoning and packaging the products. Scherer allows wheels of cheese to dry, rubbing them with salt before adding seasoning. Feta cheese is allowed to age.

Scherer said none of the milk or whey goes to waste, but is fed to the pigs and chickens, which she believes in turn produces better-tasting pork and chicken.

Then, there’s the tedious equipment cleaning, which Scherer said is the hardest part of her work.

“There’s more cleaning than anything else,” she said.

In all, Scherer works 12- to 14-hour days all milking season, using the winter to do maintenance on the equipment and buildings. Her husband Bruce works on the infrastructure and cares for the meat animals year-round.

Despite the hard work, Scherer said she wouldn’t have it any other way.

“I love goats. They’re very sweet and have very different personalities,” she said. “There’s no way I could do this if I didn’t like the animals and producing food in this holistic way.”

A Devoted Clientele

Customers can purchase The Little White Goat Dairy’s products not only at the farm, but at Amherst Farmer’s Market, Quabbin Harvest in Orange and Simple Gifts Farm in Amherst. Scherer also sells her products through the Massachusetts Local Food Cooperative, an online farmer’s market that delivers orders to pre-determined drop-off points in central Massachusetts.

“We originally thought that most of our business would be from west of here,” Scherer said. “But actually, most of our customers are from east of here.”

Scherer believes that while western Massachusetts residents can easily access locally-produced food, it becomes more difficult in central and eastern Massachusetts, attracting her business’s main customer base. Other customers, she continued, stop in for the first time on their way to vacation in the Berkshires, then start to come regularly.

“People come here and they taste the milk and the yogurt and they say ‘Wow, this is so much better than what I bought in the store,’” she said. “It’s because it’s fresh … I make the products like I’m making them for my family.”

Many customers passionately love one particular product or another, so Scherer comes to know her regulars’ orders.

“It’s developed a real following,” Scherer said of The Little White Goat Dairy. “The people who’ve decided they like it really, really like it.”

Scherer particularly prefers direct sales at Heritage Fields Farm and Amherst Farmer’s Market.

“I like to be able to meet people and talk to them about the food,” she said. Plus, it’s a great opportunity to provide samples.

Scherer said customers who come to the farm are invited to tour the facilities, explore the hiking trails or have lunch at the picnic tables along the pond. Of course, they can also get to know the goats behind the whole production.

“They kind of sell the product for me,” Scherer said, adding how happy, friendly and well-cared for the goats are. “They’re not in this stressed out environment of being a commodity … We do everything that we can to make sure they have a happy and healthy life.”

Scherer hopes to one day hold regular workshops at the farm. One idea, she said, is to have guests make their own mozzerella cheese and make pizzas together over a fire pit, or have a pig roast.

“I’d like to find ways to bring people to the farm for more than just going to the store,” she said.

Additionally, Scherer is considering expanding her business by excavating into the hillside next to the barn. With a cheese cave set in the hillside, she could offer aged cheeses as well.